United States Episodes

This week on Cold and Missing Ali and Eli look into the 2011 cold case of Jeremey Toles out of Midwest City, Oklahoma. In 2011 Jeremy had the world in front of him. He was a customer favorite at his job, had found a passion for cooking, and had just become a proud father. However, after an evening out with friends Jeremy is never heard from by his family again and he will ultimately be found by a farmer in his field a few days later. No suspects or people of interest ever emerge in this homicide. Join us as we uncover what little is known about this 2011 cold case.

This week on Cold and Missing Ali and Eli look into the unresolved missing persons case of Diamond Bynum and King Walker. This case takes place in 2015 when King is 2 and Diamond is 21. Diamond is King’s aunt however she has Prader-Willi Syndrome (PWS) a genetic condition that causes developmental delays, extreme flexibility, and excessive hunger to the point that the person can never feel full. Due to PWS Diamond’s family says she operated like a 7 year old and is unable to care for King. On July 25th, 2015 Diamond and King took a nap and shortly after they fell asleep Diamond’s step-mother also took a short nap. When she awoke at 11:00 a.m. she discovered the two were missing and quickly called police. To date there have been no confirmed sighting and no evidence of where the two could have went.

This week on Cold and Missing Ali and Eli take a look at a 1988 cold case out of San Antonio, Texas. Eight year old Jennifer Delgado and her mother were doing laundry at a laundromat located across the street from their home. A man entered the laundromat and tried to use the soda vending machine. When it malfunctioned and did not give him a soda he flew into a rage that would leave Jennifer dead. To date no suspect has ever been named in the murder. Join us this week as we take a look into this senseless cold case.

This week on Cold and Missing Ali and Eli look into the case of 3 people who went missing on Feb. 7th, 1999: Paul Skiba, Sarah Skiba, and Lorenzo Chivers. Paul owned Tuff Movers in Westminster, Colorado where Lorenzo was also employed. It was Paul’s weekend with his daughter, Sarah, so when he had to cover for an employee unexpectedly on Sunday, February 7th that would mean that Sarah would also tag along for the day. Paul, Sarah, and Lorenzo were all last seen at the final moving job of the day but none of them returned home that night. It will take days of family and friends begging and arguing with police for them to investigate. After police begrudgingly start investigating it is uncovered that a large amount of blood was spilled at Tuff Movers and Paul, Sarah, and Lorenzo are presumed dead. Join us as we go through the timeline of events in this shocking case.

This week Ali and Eli cover the cold case of Jubilee ‘Maile’ Lum from August of 1999. This cold case takes us to the island of O’ahu. Maile was last seen getting into a late 80s or early 90s Econoline van on a Monday morning. The next day by noon her body was disposed of behind a flower shop. Three flower shop employees end up making the discovery in the middle of the working day. Join as we go through this timeline of events around the cold case of Maile Lum.

This week on Cold and Missing Ali and Eli walk through the disappearance of 13 year old Myron Traylor from Phoenix Arizona. Myron and his mother were walking from their home to his granparent’s home about a mile away. Halfway there Myron asked his mom if he could stop by OK Fish & Chips to buy a cherry soda. She said yes, but to catch up with her as she continued walking. Myron was last seen in the parking lot of OK Fish & Chips with his cherry soda in hand but he would never make it to his grandparent’s home. Rumors and strange occurrences would circulate this family for years. What happened to Myron? Join us as we go through the timeline of events in this cold case.

Ali and Eli are back in the new year with a brand new cold case. This week we talk about the unsolved murder of Lesley Sparrow who’s murdered body was found October 14th, 1979 in the trunk of her own car. Lesley had been invited to a sky diving competition that weekend in Arizona but never made it out of Kentucky. Join us as we go through this 1979 unsolved murder.

This week on Cold and Missing Ali and Eli are back to talk about Tito J, Garcia Quintanilla who has been missing since August 19th, 2022. We review the interview that Ali had with Faith - Tito’s wife- that you can listen to in episodes 16 & 17. Ali and Eli go over the timeline on Tito’s journey and talk about the complex immigration system that forces people to make impossible decisions with no guaranteed outcome.

This week on Cold and Missing we’re doing something a little different. This week Ali had the chance to speak with the wife of Tito J Garcia Quintanilla who has been missing since August 19, 2022. This is part 1 of the interview with Faith. In the part of the interview you will get to know Tito and Faith- from their Rom-Com meet cute to building their life in Honduras with their son. Ali and Eli will be back next week to go over this case in detail so make sure you’re subscribed on your favorite podcast platform.

This week on Cold and Missing we’re doing something a little different. This week Ali had the chance to speak with the wife of Tito J Garcia Quintanilla who has been missing since August 19, 2022. This is part 2 of the interview with Faith, If you have not listened to part 1 we encourage you to listen to get to know Tito and Faith. In this part of the interview with Faith we will hear about the nightmare that began for this family starting with COVID-19 to Tito making his trip to America to be with his family. We’ll hear Faith talk about the last time she heard from Tito that August day and where she is today with his case. Ali and Eli will be back next week to go over this case in detail so make sure you’re subscribed on your favorite podcast platform.

Betty Rolf found herself in the middle of the first Wisconsin snowstorm in the winter of November 1988. Betty, who hated driving in the snow, decided to walk to work. The walk should have taken no time since it was about half a mile and on the same street as her home. Betty never makes it to work however. The next day her family reports her missing and she is found minutes later by police. She had been murdered and sexually assaulted and left near a railroad underpass half way between her home and work. Join Ali and Eli this week as they go through the details of this 34 year old cold case.

This week on Cold and Missing Ali and Eli dig into the unresolved missing person case of Kevin Graves. Kevin went missing from the Electric Forest Music Festival in Rothbury, Mi in 2018. After getting into a fight with his girlfriend Kevin went back to his tent to rest. Later when his girlfriend returned he could not be located. To date no sign of Kevin has ever been found. Join us as we look through what is and isn’t known about this case.

In 2021, seventeen year old Johnkelian ‘John John’ Mathis had just gotten off of work and was headed to an annual neighborhood homecoming. After the celebration crowds remained to continue to enjoy each other’s company. Shortly after 1am shots rang out and three people had been struck by the gunfire. All of them were rushed to the hospital but only one person died- John John. Join Ali and Eli as we unpack this case and try to understand this senseless crime.

In September of 1984 twelve year old Sharon Bald Eagle along with her 15 year old friend are running away from Hot Springs, North Dakota where Sharon was attending the Brainard Indian School. The girls were hitchhiking to Idaho when they were picked up near Caster, Wyoming by Royal Russell Long, Long will ultimately kidnap the two girls and tie them up at gun point. Sharon’s friend is able to escape and call for help but when police arrive Sharon and Long are gone. Sharon has never been found to date. Listen in as Ali and Eli dig through this unbelievable missing person case.

BONUS EPISODE; recent developments in the Abby Williams and Libby German case. A man named Richard Allen has been charged with two counts of murder. Listen to the episode as we go over the most recent press conference given 10/31/2022. We also review past press conferences to bring the most accurate picture available at this time.

This week Ali and Eli cover a cold case out of Etters, PA. Kimberly Yohe was 20 years old when she was last seen at her family home. Two weeks later Kimberly’s body would be found by fisherman with her arms bound behind her back. An investigation would determine that her cause of death was strangulation. To date there has been no person of interest or suspect named in this case. Join us as we comb through the known details. We also discuss the breaking news coming out of Delphi, IN in regards to Abby Williams and Libby German.

Halloween Special! This week we explore the missing person case of Ronald Tammen - also sometimes called the Phantom of Oxford. On April 19th, 1953 Ronald was last seen walking into his dorm room - Room 225 of Fisher Hall at the University of Miami Campus in Oxford, Ohio- he was never seen again. No sign or clue would ever turn up pointing to what happened to Ronald. A year after his disappearance strange sightings and sounds could be heard near and around Fisher Hall. Some students claim its Ronald. Join us this week as we dig into the ghost story and find the facts behind the lore!

This week on Cold and Missing we cover the case of Abigail ‘Abby’ Williams and Liberty ‘libby’ German who were murdered February 13th, 2017 in a small town of Delphi, Indiana while enjoying a day off from school and walking on a popular nature trail. Ali is solo in hosting this week as Eli is shooting a movie but she has yammered at him about this case since they first met because Ali used to live very close to Delphi and has personal stories of living in that area to bring a unique perspective to this case. Special attention is given to the 2021 and 2022 updates on the case.

On December 18th, 2016 Joanna ‘Jino’ Wright- a beloved member of the Marquette Park neighborhood and LGBTQIA+ community in Chicago - was abducted in the middle of the day. Despite several witnesses to the abduction she still remains missing today. Listen as Ali and Eli comb through the case this week on Cold and Missing

This week on Cold and Missing Ali and Eli dive into the cold case of family man John Leonard, Sr. In 1970 John was working as a taxi driver when he received a request for a short ride. John would be found dead in his cab due to 4 gunshot wounds at The Inn at Buck Hill Falls. No suspects are ever announced in the case. A few years later his wife gets a tip about his murder and the next morning she’ll be found dead after a car accident. Her death will be ruled an accident. Join us as we comb through the details of this cold case.

On December 26th, 1995 Jessica Kinsey is 14 years old and at a friends house showing off her Christmas gifts when a supposed family friend picked her up without any warning. Instead of taking her home 23 year old Jimmy Hopkins takes her to Indiana where she is never seen again. Jimmy will resurface in Jessica’s hometown months later without Jessica. Join Ali and Eli this week and this dig into this missing person case from 1995.

On December 5th, 2001, 70 year old Margie Dabney was traveling from Indianapolis, IN to their home is Bakersfield, CA. During their flight they were going to have a short layover at the Dallas/For Worth airport to switch planes. Somewhere between gate 35 and gate 39 Margie Dabney disappeared. To further complicate the search Margie was suffering from Alzheimers. It would take almost 6 years to find her body and after an autopsy it was revealed her death was caused by a homicide, Join us this week while Ali and Eli dive into the case.

On July 2nd, 1999 middle schooler Trevell Henley was last seen walking to a friends house by his little brother. That was the last time Trevell was seen alive. Later, police discover evidence of a homicide but to date Trevell has never been found and no one has been prosecuted for this crime. Join us this week as we dive into the details around the case and discuss why more hasn’t been done to bring Trevell home. To learn more about Black and Missing Foundation please visit https://www.black...

On April 17th, 1983 high school senior Corinne Perry heads to a local laundromat on a Sunday evening. A man follows her as she leaves the laundromat and she is never heard from again. November 3rd, 1984 after missing for over a year and half her bones are found by hunters. Join us this week as we dive into this cold case.