Pennsylvania Episodes

In this episode of Cold and Missing, we delve into the tragic case of 8-year-old Debra "Debbie" Makel, who went missing on October 5, 1973, from Rices Landing, PA. After a seemingly ordinary day at school, Debbie vanished shortly after getting off the bus, leaving her family and community in shock. Despite extensive searches, her body was found two days later, revealing a heartbreaking crime scene that shook the small town. Despite officers running down every lead and tip that came in the case w...

This week on Cold and Missing Ali and Eli look into the 2000 unresolved missing person case of Aesha Muhammad. In Nov. of 2000 Aesha was having issues with her landlord and had made plans to move in with her sister. When family suddenly stopped being able to reach Aesha they became increasingly worried not only for her, but also for her 2 1/2 year old Amaru. A few days later Amaru turns up at the front door of a church during their Sunday service. He is unharmed but Aesha is no where to be found. Once Amaru is reunited with his family he begins to tell them what he knows. That his mommy is dead and she was hit on the head. Join us as we go over this tragic unresolved missing person case.

This week Ali and Eli cover a cold case out of Etters, PA. Kimberly Yohe was 20 years old when she was last seen at her family home. Two weeks later Kimberly’s body would be found by fisherman with her arms bound behind her back. An investigation would determine that her cause of death was strangulation. To date there has been no person of interest or suspect named in this case. Join us as we comb through the known details. We also discuss the breaking news coming out of Delphi, IN in regards to Abby Williams and Libby German.

This week on Cold and Missing Ali and Eli dive into the cold case of family man John Leonard, Sr. In 1970 John was working as a taxi driver when he received a request for a short ride. John would be found dead in his cab due to 4 gunshot wounds at The Inn at Buck Hill Falls. No suspects are ever announced in the case. A few years later his wife gets a tip about his murder and the next morning she’ll be found dead after a car accident. Her death will be ruled an accident. Join us as we comb through the details of this cold case.